Declarative and Enforceable Custody Protection in Indonesia and Malaysia: A Study on the Best Interest of the Child in Islamic Family Law

Authors

  • N Rubaia Author

Keywords:

child custody rights;, Islamic family law; Ḥaḍānah;, legal systems; Maqāṣid al-Sharī‘ah.

Abstract

When it comes to protecting children after a divorce, Islamic family law relies heavily
on the best interest of the kid premise. The implementation and juridical ramifications of this
concept differ greatly among legal systems, notwithstanding its widespread recognition in statutes
and court practices. With a focus on the legal ramifications stemming from variations in their
normative and procedural designs, this paper compares and contrasts Islamic family law in
Indonesia and Malaysia in regards to the regulation and implementation of the best interest of the
child concept. Using a comparative and doctrinal approach to normative legal research, this study
examines Islamic family law and child protection statutes, court rulings, and academic works from
both jurisdictions. In order to evaluate the connection between the determination of custody and the
implementation of court judgements, the analytical framework utilises the ideas of ḥaḍānah and
maqāṣid al-sharīʿah. Evidence from both Indonesia and Malaysia shows that Islamic family law
uses the best interest of the child as its guiding concept when deciding who gets custody of a kid.
Nevertheless, different legal results result from different arrangements of normative and procedural
factors. In Indonesia, the majority of child custody protection cases are handled via a process
known as declarative justice, where legal rights are established by court rulings but lack effective
enforcement measures. By contrast, Islamic family law in Malaysia incorporates custody decisions
with enforcement mechanisms and legal penalties for non-compliance, reflecting a paradigm of
custody protection as enforced justice. These results highlight how Islamic family law prioritises
the involvement of normative recognition in shaping child protection policies, but also how much
weight legal systems give to the idea of enforceable institutional structures to back up custody
decisions.

Downloads

Published

2026-02-16